4 answers To The Tisha Baav Riddle

 לז"נ הקדוש ר' משה בן  ר' ישיעהו הי"ד           
     נעקד"ה  ג' אב ע"י הגרמנים הארורים ימ"ש  
--------------------------------------------------------------------
There are four reasons why Mr.Fester won't make Havdala on Sunday night

1) He heard from a Choleh who made Havdalah on Tisha Baav   and he had in mind to be Yotzei.

2) He is Rachmana Litzlan  an Onnen on Sunday night.

3) He broke his fast by drinking water.

4) He became a Ger on Motzei Shabbos

Many answered He made Havdalah on 
Shabbos after Plag.

According to Mori V'Rabi Harav Hagaon
R. Shlomo Miller Shlita, One can not
make Havdalah (Al Hakos) after Plag on 
Shabbos Erev Tisha Bav
because immediately after Havdalah 
he would need to start his fast and won't be
able to drink the wine.




1)  עיין שערי תשובה ס' תקנ"ו ס"ק א' בשם הברכ"י 
"חולה המבדיל יכול להוציא ב"ב"
4) רק ע"פ האריז"ל אסור לשתות אפילו מים  קודם הבדלה

Special thanks to all those who contributed with
the correct answers (too many to list )
When I asked the question I only had two answers.

No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

The Satmar Rebbe

  Parshas Hashavua אחרי  The Satmar Rebbe, R Yoilish Teitelbaum Zt"l was asked why he was so harsh and critical of כלל ישראל . Why co...